Indonesia’s Collective Amnesia


By: Endy Bayuni

Last week, the National Commission on Human Rights, an independent state body, released its findings from a four-year investigation into the 1965 purge of suspected communists.

The commission concludes that the Army-led campaign amounted to a gross violation of human rights. It urged the government to prosecute the perpetrators and compensate victims and survivors. It also called upon President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono to issue a public apology.

But the report failed to generate much public interest, if the reaction of the country’s major newspapers is any indication. They either ignored the story or buried it in the inside pages — which made for a jarring contrast to the hysterical headlines devoted to shooting in faraway Denver recently. But then the mainstream media have always been complicit in the conspiracy of silence over the killings, whether knowingly or out of ignorance.

The killing campaign in 1965 and 1966 was unleashed after an abortive coup against president Sukarno in October 1965 that the Army blamed on the Indonesian Communist Party (PKI). Although the massacre happened on Sukarno’s watch, he had by then become a lame-duck president.

The report instead put the blame squarely on the Command for the Restoration of Security and Order led by Gen. Soeharto, who went on to become president in 1967. The commission’s recommendation only says that those most responsible should be prosecuted, though it gives no specific names.

In spite of its massive scale, the killing campaign has been shrouded in mystery. No one — the Human Rights Commission included — has ever been able to put a figure on how many were killed. Estimates range from a conservative 200,000 to as many as 3 million, a figure once boastingly cited by Sarwo Edhie Wibowo, who headed the military campaign at the time as chief of the Army’s Special Forces.

The Soeharto regime banned any discussion of the entire episode, including the massacre and the circumstances surrounding the transfer of power. For more than three decades, only the military’s version of history was allowed to circulate. The veil of silence was lifted only some years after Soeharto stepped down in 1998.

Official history books today still treat the episode as an attempt by the PKI, then the world’s largest communist party in a non-communist state, to grab power. They make no mention of the ensuing massacre of party members, their sympathizers and relatives, and even many innocent bystanders, or the harsh treatments meted out to the survivors in the aftermath of the killings.

The report, the most detailed study ever carried out on the massacre, lists the types of crimes committed, including murder, slavery, forced disappearances, limits to physical freedom, torture, rape, persecution and forced prostitution. It also says the killing was widespread across most major islands in the archipelago, and not confined to Java, Sumatra and Bali, as had been widely believed. The study also identified at least 17 mass graves where the victims were buried.

Although Indonesians who went through the period are aware of the killings, most have turned a blind eye, and many have even managed to erase them from memory. They accepted the official version that the military had saved Indonesia from communism, and, by logical conclusion, that Soeharto and his military cohorts were the heroes of the day.

Time will tell how far the report will go to break these long years of the conspiracy of silence about the killings, and whether it will succeed in jolting the nation out of its collective amnesia. The report also calls for the establishment of a truth and reconciliation commission to look into the tragedy.

Scholars attempting to study the killings say that many of the perpetrators and the surviving victims have refused to be interviewed for events that they said were too traumatic to recount. A few, however, have been brave enough to break their silence, as captured in the film documentary 40 Years of Silence — An Indonesian Tragedy.

President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, for whom the report was prepared, responded positively by ordering the office of the attorney general to look into the recommendations, including considering the prosecution of those most responsible for the killings. His office has also said that the President is considering an official apology on behalf of the state for all the human rights violations committed against its own citizens.

All the key players in the killing campaign, however, are dead: Soeharto died in 2008, his deputy Adm. Sudomo this past April, and Sarwo Edhie, in 1989. It will be interesting to see how far the Indonesian Military, or Yudhoyono for that matter, are prepared to see their seniors tried in absentia or be dragged through the dirt in the event that the truth and reconciliation commission is formed. Yudhoyono, a military general himself, is the son-in-law of Sarwo Edhie.

Many human rights activists have their doubts. They note that a report by the same commission about the mass rape of Chinese-Indonesians during rioting in 1998 never received any follow-up from the office of the attorney general.

The release of the report was hailed as a milestone by a handful of victims and survivors who had been seeking justice all these years. For most Indonesians, it was a non-event.

In one of the rare public reactions to the report, Priyo Budi Santoso, a senior politician from the Golkar Party, said that wallowing in the past was unproductive for the nation.

“It is better if we move forward,” said Priyo, whose party provided the political machine that sustained Soeharto in power for more than three decades.

Tragically, he probably spoke for most of the people in this country.

Anyone wondering why the systemic culture of impunity, and with it the culture of violence, are so notoriously strong in Indonesia, may have found the answer this week. They are deeply embedded, along with the nation’s collective amnesia.


Notice: This opinion article was displayed in an online newspaper, The Jakarta Post, in Jakarta, Indonesia, on Wednesday, August 1, 2012; and in paper edition is page 7. It is able also to be searched at: [accessed in Bandung, West Java, Indonesia: 3 August 2012].

The writer is senior editor of The Jakarta Post. This article first appeared in the Transitions section of Foreign Policy magazine’s website



  1. I think it is the big dilemma. But let’s we see the history objectively. In that time, there were triangle struggle between Army (TNI-AD), Communist (PKI), and Soekarno (President). Whoever become the winner, the rest will be suppressed from Indonesian history. And in those struggle, the Army is the winner. As its consequences, the PKI and Soekarno were forced to step down from history. Let’s also imagine if the Communist is as the winner. I think the historical events like in Cambodia (Pholphot regime) or in other Communist countries will become the story so tragically. Salam “Historia Magistra Vitae”.

  2. I absolutely agree with Prof Dr Taufik Abdullah’s opinion that if the victims of Communist want to be restored from history, how about the victims of DII/TII or PRRI/PERMESTA in Indonesian history?

    What we can do from history is that we get the wisely and let’s learn from the past events in order we can prepare the future good things.

  3. Saya curigesyen nih, jangan2 yang menuduh adanya pelanggaran HAM dan menuntut permintaan maaf atas peristiwa G-30-S tahun 1965 itu adalah anak-anaknya PKI. Mereka tidak sadar bahwa PKI juga telah melakukan aksi2 sepihak menjelang terjadinya peristiwa G-30-S itu dengan menduduki tanah-tanah wakaf milik kyai dan tanah-tanah perkebunan milik negara dengan alasan ideologi “sama rata sama rasa”. Mereka juga (orang2 PKI itu) menghina Tuhan dengan menyatakan “Gusti Allah wis mati”. Akibatnya, ketika gerakan 30 September 1965 dimana PKI terlibat itu gagal, maka menjadi wajar jika mereka diburu dan disikat habis tidak hanya oleh tentara AD tetapi juga oleh umat Islam Indonesia.

    Anda ingin tahu dimana Muso dan Aidit sekarang berada? Insya Allah di neraka jahanam, jadi keraknya api neraka. Wassalam.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here